Analysing the CJEU’s 2022 judgment on public access to beneficial ownership information, privacy and the future of AML transparency in the EU
Executive Summary
The Court of Justice of the European Union held in WM and Sovim that EU legislation requiring beneficial ownership information relating to companies and other legal entities to be accessible, in all cases, to any member of the general public was invalid. The Court found that this form of unrestricted public access amounted to a serious interference with the rights to privacy and protection of personal data under Articles 7 and 8 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights (the ‘Charter’), and that the measure was not limited to what was strictly necessary or proportionate to the AML/CFT objective pursued.
The judgment did not abolish beneficial ownership registers, nor did it affect access by competent authorities, financial intelligence units or obliged entities carrying out customer due diligence. What it rejected, was automatic access for every member of the public regardless of purpose, while confirming that AML/CFT transparency remains legitimate and important.
For compliance professionals, the practical significance of the case lies in its insistence on structured proportionality. Beneficial ownership data may be collected, maintained and disclosed for legitimate AML/CFT purposes, but access must be tied to a lawful purpose, limited in scope and supported by adequate safeguards. That reasoning remains highly relevant for current debates around legitimate-interest access, online registries and the intersection of AML compliance with data protection.
The judgment directly concerned Article 30 of Directive (EU) 2015/849, which applies to companies and other legal entities, and not the separate trust regime under Article 31. Even so, its reasoning has broader importance for trusts and similar legal arrangements, because later EU legislation now frames access to beneficial ownership information for both legal entities and legal arrangements around the concept of legitimate interest rather than unrestricted public access.
In the trust context, the case indirectly supports a position that many practitioners have long recognised: confidentiality may form part of the legitimate legal and commercial rationale of a trust structure, but confidentiality is not secrecy. Trustees, service providers and other relevant persons remain under full AML/CFT obligations, and authorities and obliged entities must retain the access they need to conduct effective verification, supervision and customer due diligence.
Why the Judgment Matters
Case C-37/20, WM and Sovim is one of the most important recent CJEU decisions on the relationship between transparency and fundamental rights in the AML space. It confirms that the public-policy objective of preventing money laundering and terrorist financing, however important, does not remove the need for a rigorous Charter analysis where personal data is concerned.
The judgment also matters because it draws a careful distinction between different stages of beneficial ownership regulation. Gathering information, maintaining central registers, permitting access to competent authorities and obliged entities, and disclosing information to third parties are legally distinct steps and must not be treated as interchangeable. That distinction is particularly useful for professionals advising on AML governance, beneficial ownership compliance and data protection by design.
Legal Background
Directive (EU) 2015/849, the Fourth Anti-Money Laundering Directive, required companies and other legal entities incorporated within Member States to obtain and hold adequate, accurate and current information on their beneficial ownership and required Member States to place that information in central registers. Under the original model, competent authorities and financial intelligence units had unrestricted access, obliged entities had access for customer due diligence, and other persons or organisations could obtain access where they demonstrated a legitimate interest.
Directive (EU) 2018/843, the Fifth Anti-Money Laundering Directive, changed that model by amending Article 30(5)(c) so that specified beneficial ownership information had to be made accessible, in all cases, to any member of the general public. The information included the beneficial owner’s name, month and year of birth, nationality, country of residence, and the nature and extent of the beneficial interest held.
Luxembourg implemented that requirement through its Law of 13 January 2019 establishing the Register of Beneficial Ownership. Under that regime, certain beneficial ownership information could be consulted by any person, including online, subject to limited exemptions in exceptional circumstances where access would expose the beneficial owner to disproportionate risk.
Facts Of the Joined Cases
In Case C-37/20, a Luxembourg real estate company asked Luxembourg Business Registers to restrict access to the information identifying WM as its beneficial owner. It argued that disclosure would expose WM and his family to serious risks because his professional activities involved travel to politically unstable regions with elevated criminal risk. The application was rejected, and that refusal was challenged before the Luxembourg District Court.
In Case C-601/20, Sovim SA also sought to restrict public access to information concerning its beneficial owner. After its request was refused, Sovim challenged the compatibility of the public-access regime with the Charter and raised additional arguments linked to EU data-protection principles.
The Luxembourg court referred questions to the CJEU concerning both the validity of the EU public-access rule and the interpretation of the exemption mechanism, including the meaning of exceptional circumstances and disproportionate risk.
Issue Before the Court
The central issue was whether Article 1(15)(c) of Directive (EU) 2018/843 was valid insofar as it amended Article 30(5)(c) of Directive (EU) 2015/849 to require Member States to make beneficial ownership information concerning companies and other legal entities accessible, in all cases, to any member of the general public.
The Court examined that question primarily through the lens of Articles 7 and 8 of the Charter, read together with Article 52(1), which requires that limitations on Charter rights be provided for by law, respect the essence of those rights and satisfy the requirements of necessity and proportionality.
The Court’s Reasoning
Interference with Privacy and Personal Data
The Court first held that public access to beneficial ownership information interfered with both the right to respect for private and family life and the right to protection of personal data. The fact that some of the information related to professional or economic activity did not remove it from the scope of Articles 7 and 8.
The Court described the interference as serious. The information made available could allow a relatively detailed profile to be drawn concerning the beneficial owner’s identity, wealth and investments, and the fact that the information could be consulted online meant that an unlimited number of persons could access, retain and further disseminate it, including for purposes unrelated to AML/CFT.
Legitimate Objective but Insufficient Limits
The Court accepted that the prevention of money laundering and terrorist financing is an objective of general interest capable of justifying serious interferences with fundamental rights. It also accepted that a higher degree of transparency can contribute to that objective by making misuse of corporate vehicles more difficult.
The difficulty for the legislature was not the objective itself, but the breadth of the mechanism chosen. In the Court’s view, replacing the earlier legitimate-interest test with universal public access was not shown to be strictly necessary. The absence of a harmonised EU definition of legitimate interest did not justify abandoning the concept altogether and opening access to everyone.
Necessity, Proportionality and Safeguards
The Court placed particular emphasis on strict necessity and proportionality. It noted that the previous legitimate-interest model had already allowed access for categories such as journalists, civil-society organisations active in AML/CFT work and persons likely to enter into transactions with the relevant entity, all of whom may have a real need for the information.
By contrast, a regime granting access to any member of the public regardless of any connection to the AML/CFT objective went further than necessary. The Court also considered that the legislative safeguards were insufficient. The wording of Article 30(5) allowed access to at least certain categories of information and permitted Member States to add further data, while optional online registration and case-by-case exemptions were not enough to restore a fair balance between transparency and the rights protected by the Charter.
Decision
The Grand Chamber declared Article 1(15)(c) of Directive (EU) 2018/843 invalid insofar as it amended Article 30(5)(c) of Directive (EU) 2015/849 to require Member States to make beneficial ownership information concerning companies and other legal entities accessible, in all cases, to any member of the general public.
Once the Court reached that conclusion, it did not answer the remaining questions concerning the exemption regime, including the detailed meaning of exceptional circumstances, risk and disproportionate risk, or the separate GDPR arguments raised before the national court.
Commentary and Practical Significance
The decision is best understood not as a rejection of beneficial ownership transparency, but as a rejection of indiscriminate public disclosure. It leaves intact the wider architecture of beneficial ownership compliance and confirms that central registers, disclosure obligations and regulatory access continue to serve a legitimate AML/CFT function.
Its real significance lies in the discipline it imposes on lawmakers, regulators and practitioners. Where beneficial ownership information concerns identifiable natural persons, access design must be justified with precision. The lawful purpose must be clear, the scope of disclosure must be limited to what is necessary, and the safeguards must be real rather than cosmetic.
That reasoning has immediate operational value for compliance and data-protection practice. It reinforces the need to distinguish between data collection, record-keeping, supervisory access, customer due diligence access, and third-party disclosure. Each stage involves a different legal justification and a different risk profile.
The case also had visible consequences in Cyprus. Following the judgment, the Cyprus Registrar of Companies suspended general-public access to the Register of Beneficial Owners on 23 November 2022. At EU level, the recalibrated legislative response can now be seen in Directive (EU) 2024/1640, which frames access for both legal entities and legal arrangements around legitimate interest rather than automatic public access.
Trust Implications
The judgment did not directly decide the rules governing trusts and similar legal arrangements under Article 31 of Directive (EU) 2015/849. Its direct subject matter was Article 30 and access to beneficial ownership information relating to companies and other legal entities.
Even so, the judgment is relevant to trusts in two important respects. First, it reflects a broader EU movement towards balancing AML/CFT transparency with privacy and data protection, rather than equating transparency with unrestricted public access. Second, that policy balance is now expressly reflected in the later EU framework, which adopts a legitimate-interest model for access to beneficial ownership information concerning both legal entities and legal arrangements.
For Cyprus trust practice, the lesson is not that trust beneficial ownership information should disappear from regulatory view. The lesson is that confidentiality and compliance are not opposites. A trust structure may legitimately preserve a degree of privacy from the general public while remaining fully subject to disclosure obligations towards competent authorities, supervisors and obliged entities carrying out AML/CFT checks.
That makes the case particularly relevant when considering the evolution of CyTBOR access rules and the wider relationship between AML compliance and data protection in trust administration. It supports a more precise vocabulary in practice: not secrecy, not anonymity, but regulated confidentiality within a robust AML/CFT framework.
Concluding Remarks
WM and Sovim remains a leading authority on how EU law balances beneficial ownership transparency against privacy and personal-data protection. The key takeaway is straightforward: AML/CFT transparency remains essential, but access to beneficial ownership data cannot be unlimited, purposeless or weakly safeguarded.
For lawyers, fiduciaries, compliance officers and data-protection advisers, the case is also a reminder that the architecture of access matters as much as the obligation to file information in the first place. That is why the judgment continues to matter not only for company beneficial ownership registers, but also for the design of trust-related compliance systems and privacy-sensitive disclosure regimes more broadly.
Stelios Hadjithomas
LLB, MA, LLM European Public Law
Associate Advocate | AML Compliance Supervisor
M. Paraschou Law
This article is intended for general information only and does not constitute legal advice.
Contact us today to discuss how we can support your legal and compliance needs.

📞 Call us: 00357 22 622 262
📧 Email us: info@paraschou.com.cy
🌐 Visit: www.paraschou.com.cy
Read our Additional Articles Here:
